Open the .mimic file and look for the relevant OID:
.1.3.6.1.2.1.14.7.1.12.<IPAddress>.0
which tells us the status OSPF niehbour relationship.
It may not say DOWN, but declares a invalid interface type - loopback instead of the actual interface.
FIX: Deleting All gateway routers, and their corresponding events, and then rediscovering the gateway router solved this issue. Another more drastic fix would be to start the NPM domain with a fresh RPS.