There is a difference in performance when running a Datacom DBUTLTY EXTRACT and physical BACKUP against the same area.
The EXTRACT is much slower than the BACKUP. It uses more CPU and EXCPs,
Release : 15.0, 15.1
Component : DATACOM/DB
The reason the EXTRACT takes longer to run is that it has to un-compress the records first. By default the BACKUP specifies CMPRS=YES which leaves the records compressed in the backup. This is explained in the documentation section Back Up Data Area
There are some things you can do to speed up the EXTRACT mentioned in the documentation section When to Use EXTRACT:
Also see article 18772 - Is there an easy way to speed up CA Datacom DBUTLTY BACKUP or EXTRACT processing?